Clarins Waterproof Eye Pencil 01 Black Tulip

I was hoping for a pencil that would have a bit more staying power on ageing eyelids but I didn’t find it here. It’s a bit better than my non- waterproof one but it didn’t last the day. It has a really annoying removable little smudger on the end which would be great but pings off when you take the cap off it.

Disappointed with this pencil. It doesn't last very long and because of the plastic casing it is impossible to know how much is left. The last centimetre or so is very hard to use as it falls out of the casing. Not a good design. I'm afraid I won't be buying again and intend to find a proper pencil from somewhere else.

I only use eye pencils from Clarins, gentle to eyes and last whole day

Eye pencil is soft, so you need to retract it completely before replacing cap, or you squash it and lose some!

Colour was as hoped but it lasted just one month with the last bit dropping off as there is so little in it