Rimmel Mascara Supercurler - Extreme Black 003

Terrible. There is no curl to this. None. The brush is big and clumsy. The formula is sticky and with anything over one coat it clumps and glues lashes together. It lenghtens, but it looks bad. My eyes didn't itch or water but my undereye area became red, swollen and burning within minutes after application. It took 9 cotton balls and garnier's pink micellar water to remove. I still kept getting those ugly black floaters throughout the day. Mess on upper eyelid upon application. This is the second worst mascara I've tried in the past 20 years. It's 9 €, which I think is not that little, for such a piece of... work. I threw it out 25 minutes after paying for it (no returns on opened cosmetics, because you can definitely try them without opening them). I'm done with Rimmel. Nail Nurse has been their only acceptable product I've tried so far.

This isn't a bad mascara, but it's not especially good. It gives a little bit of curl, but it doesn't hold it. Volume is pretty good! And it separates your lashes well. About 50% of the time I get mascara on my upper lid, which is...annoying to say the least. For me it doesn't flake too badly, but it does get irritating after a while - perhaps my tube is just a little old. Not waterproof, but it does resist coming off with water...which is good? I guess? Not a bad mascara, but I'll try other drugstore brands before I buy this again.

The brush is nice but that's pretty much all the "pros" of this mascara. The formula is bad, it makes my lashes clamp together badly (even after removing excess mascara from the brush), it's difficult to remove without proper makeup remover and it does NOT curl your lashes at all! Unfortunately I don't think I can even use it up - waste of money (Rimmel - again!).

A lot of people don't like this mascara, but I actually really like it! It adds a lot of volume to my lashes, but I still have to use my eyelash curler. I love the wand as well and it applies the product in an even coat. The mascara was super black too. One of my drugstore favorites!

I disliked this product right after trying it the first time. The only thing I like about it is the wand. It builds up alright, but it does not last. After a few hours it starts flaking. It may have made my eyes water, which would then easily smudge. Once this flakes and gets into your eyes it is so irritating. I wear contacts and if it gets in my eyes I have to take my contacts out. Now I'm wary of buying any rimmel mascara. Also, trying to wash this stuff off is harder than my previous mascara. It's runs easily, but it's hard to get it off the skin with my mild cleansers. And when I'm feeling lazy I can't get it all off and end up waking up to black smudges by my eyes.